Vancouver’s legendary Don’t Argue! Pizza is reopening in a new neighbourhood

potato pizza and pepperoni pizza from don't argue pizza

For all the pizza fanatics in Vancouver, the pizza gods are shining down on Vancouver with the return of a local legend. The much-loved and missed Don’t Argue! Pizza is sliding back into our hearts and stomachs with a fresh twist, setting up shop inside the cozy and charming confines of CAFFÈ SOCCAVO on Commercial Drive, right in the heart of East Van.

The new slice shop will be opening March 9th and will have some of the fan favs returning and some new creatives like the iconic Margherita in both classic and spicy, Pancetta Pineapple, Pesto Ricotta and  Potato Mash (topped with whipped potato, red onion, and braised kale) – it’s a menu designed to demolish any pizza craving in sight.

The original Don’t Argue! Pizza burst onto the scene on Main Street, quickly becoming the go-to spot for authentic New York-style pizza in Vancouver. It was the kind of place where the slices were so good, debates over who made the best pizza in town often ended with its name. Sadly, in 2019, this cozy counter-service joint closed its doors, leaving a pepperoni-shaped hole in our hearts. But dreams do come true and the legend is making a comeback under new ownership by the brother owners of another icon, Via Tevere Pizzeria, and of course CAFFÈ SOCCAVO.

Don’t Argue! Slice Shop will take over half of CAFFÈ SOCCAVO’s 40-seat space, with the other half staying the café sipping, soccer watching and definitely a lot of arguing over Inter Milan and Juventus.

“We’re buzzing with excitement to breathe new life into one of Vancouver’s pizza legends and serve it up in a fresh format within our little slice of Italy. Reviving Don’t Argue! Pizza within CAFFÈ SOCCAVO is our way of paying tribute to a neighborhood gem while dishing out legendary slices to new and loyal fans alike.” – Domo Morra, owner of Don’t Argue! Slice Shop.

The slice shop will be dishing out pizza love from 11am to 8pm on the regular, with extended hours until 10pm on weekends. If you go for their opening on Saturday, March 9th, the first 100 customers get free pizza and the rest only pay $3 for a slice.

When | Opening March 9th, 2024
Where | 1321 Commercial Drive, Vancouver Canada
Website | Instagram

a group of men sitting outside eating pizza

    Leave Your Comment

    Forgot Password